Hi yes although its been 4 years since I posted a message on the above, I am pleased you contacted me and would like to keep up contact with you am keen to know more on your line from Richard Noble, fascinated by your information and hope you will look at my tree on ancestry. and am keen to view your tree, Also keen to add this information and also James's Sons, also am on rootsweb, with a tree. Would like to add more New York information from 1860 onwards re Catling and Noble families appreciate you getting in touch. Many posts I put on here, replies are few and far between, So hope to hear from you soon. Thanks again Karen.