Looking at http://www.historicaldirectories.org/hd/
again, looks like there are 2 John Eabrys, both arriving in and leaving Leicester around the same time. (John March Eabry died in 1886).
I wrongly assumed that, like my Butlers, one address was Home, and the other was Business - the fact that in some entries John March Eabry is listed as just John Eabry didn't help. To add to the confusion, John March Eabry was a Shopkeeper. John Eabry and family members are variously described as Shopkeepers or Beer Retailers and Shopkeepers!! John March Eabry lived and worked at 62 Buckingham Street.
Will email other info in case that helps with finding a link.