Search for content in message boards

irishgenealogy.ie Date Accuracy??

Replies: 16

irishgenealogy.ie Date Accuracy??

Posted: 24 Sep 2011 9:28AM GMT
Classification: Query
This website has been extremely helpful, but I question the integrity of the dates displayed. Most identify the source of the dates as either "assumed" or "based on other information". Here's what I'm finding:

In my U.S. research I discovered that my great-grandmother's(Catherine) maiden name was Cavanaugh (Kevane) and that they came from Kerry. I found out that Catherine and John McDonnell had 5 kids Michael, Patrick, Catherine, Margaret and Ellen. I found only one marriage record for John McDonnell and Catherine Kevane for 1850 (Ballyferriter), but found the baptism records for Catherine, Margaret and Patrick in the same Parish with parents John and Catherine Kevane, but their birth dates were 1838, 1843 and 1846. Those dates are all off by 6-8 years compared to the US records. I then found baptism records for Michael and Ellen in a different parish (dingle) with the same 1854 date, which is close to what I have for Michael in US, but 4 years off for Ellen.

Before I dismiss these records, I wanted to see if anyone else has encountered issues with the dates on this site. If these are the only ones listed on the site with the appropriate names and its not them, can I assume they were not registered with a church?
SubjectAuthorDate Posted
Gerald McDona... 24 Sep 2011 3:28PM GMT 
franmalone39 28 Sep 2011 11:55PM GMT 
Gerald McDona... 29 Sep 2011 12:33AM GMT 
franmalone39 29 Sep 2011 2:58PM GMT 
Gerald McDona... 29 Sep 2011 6:19PM GMT 
moneill128 22 Nov 2012 10:48PM GMT 
Gerald McDona... 24 Nov 2012 3:27AM GMT 
EMCOUNIHAN 29 Sep 2011 2:03AM GMT 
moneill128 22 Nov 2012 10:45PM GMT 
wrquinn 29 Sep 2011 8:35AM GMT 
per page

Find a board about a specific topic

  • Visit our other sites:

© 1997-2014 Ancestry.com | Corporate Information | Privacy | Terms and Conditions