Michael ALEXIE arrived in 1885 and a notation Na- naturalized.
Have you looked into his naturalization intent and petition?
The census taker has the ancestors Slovenian. Is this a mistake and it should be Slovakian?http://www.carpatho-rusyn.org/http://www.c-rs.org/
I would suggest posting on all the boards that apply to your research. Sometimes the godparents of the first US born child was from the same village in "old country".