I will check over at St Mary's. There seems to be some confusion about this family & maybe I will find out some answers for sure. On Mathilda's death certificate it lists her father as Ferdinand Schaefer (not Stephen) so I've never been sure if that was their immigration record in 1867. The Taylor obit for Mathilda just said she was from Germany but I will check to see if there was anything else that was printed that was in German that might give more detail. Sounds like I have a project for April!
PS.Do you have access to St Mary's records online?