Thank you so much for getting back to me. Wow! This is quite a family with quite a bit of interesting events. I enjoyed reading the article on the murder.
I am correct with my research that Isabella Hughey married Henry Sutton (marriage certificate says William Henry Sutton) in 1905. This matches what you have.
You mention that Robert Hughey and James Hughey had a sister Sarah Ann. Do you think this is the Sarah Ann Hughey that married John Noble? Their daughter Isabella Noble married Robert Sutton in 1907.
There were 4 children of Phoebe Cox and William Sutton. Florence (my grandmother), Louisa (located her family line to date), Henry Sutton and Robert Sutton are the two that I am working on now. I grew up in Newmarket and I know that there are plots at the cemetery there for this family but I have not had the opportunity to get back there to take a look.