Yes, it is Sugar Grove Methodist Church. The church is still there, but the records were held by church members and have been lost over the years. I tried a few years ago to locate burial records and that's what I was told.
If you want to email me the people you're looking for I might be able to help though. Especially with the Hutson surname. I'm related to a lot of people in this cemetery and have many photos. I've entered some on www.findagrave.com
and some I still have on my computer waiting to be entered.