Is this the family you have?

1860 Jefferson County, IL Census

ALBERT GIBBS 40, KY
Mary A. 44, TN
Sarah 14, TN
George H. 11, TN
William 20, TN

GIBBS, ALBERT DUNAWAY, MARY ANN 1853-10-10 (Jefferson Co., IL Marriage)

1870 Jefferson County, IL Census

ALBERT GIBBS 51, KY
Elizabeth 35, TN
George 23, TN
Charles 5, IL
Elvira 3, IL
Eudora 7/12, IL

GIBBS, ALBERT ROGERS, ELIZABETH 1862-12-24
(FRANKLIN County, IL Marriage)
(Is this him or a different one?)

1850 Montgomery County, TN

ALBERT GIBBS 35, Miss
Sarah 36, NC
John J. 15, TN
William H. 9, TN
George H. 2, TN
Mary C. 11, TN
Nancy J. 6, TN
Sarah E. 4, TN

If so, the obituary of George H. GIBBS says that he was born in Henderson County, TN and came to Illinois in 1853 and spent most of his life in Jefferson Co. His wife was Mary E. DUNCAN.

Here are two abstract companies in Mt. Vernon, IL.
Jefferson County Title Company
716 Main St.
Mt. Vernon, IL
618-242-3212

The other one is associated with the
Sharp Law Offices
1115 Harrison
Mt. Vernon, IL
618-242-0246
800-769-7000

Mary