Thank you, Jill. I do not think this was him.
I believe he came from Dublin, but not sure. That is what I am trying to figure out. Catherine's father lived with the couple for a little while. They seemed to have moved around a lot.

Will check out your site as I have family on the other side of the tree from Mayo...Kiltimagh and Bohola areas. Roach, Kilgallen, and Mulloy.