Yes - she is my Anna!
I have been in contact with St Paul's Lutheran Church and they graciously found her entry in their funeral / death records. According to their records she was buried in a cemetery new the town of Ira. It is believed she was not buried in the St Paul Cemetery. The only cemetery I've been able to locate is the one on Swan Creek Rd - and keep hoping someone has a record of who is buried there as it is quite a drive for me to go there.