I know the original thread to this tread is very old but just in case someone is still looking for Wagner information I thought I'd post. I grew up in Colon and still live not far away. I still go back to camp out on the Farm that's been in the family since 1868. I have two brothers and several Wagner cousins still living in Colon or the surrounding area. Then there are several lady cousins who's maiden names are Wagner.
We are decedents of George Wagner who came to Colon in 1868. He first lived in Three Rivers MI in the early 60s coming from Snyder County PA. His Brother Henry also moved to the area, Sherman Township. Their Father was George D Wagner of Crossgrove Hall, West Beaver Twp, Snyder Co, PA.