As stated in previous post, Kate's father name was Paul and he was a stone or brick mason. The following 1870 census shows a daughter name Elfretta. I have no idea how the census take came up with the name from Kate Ella, but I have seen worse. The age of Elfretta and her father's occupation matches the clues I have. This is why I was hoping to contact some one from Kate and Earl Nash's family to confirm if I am on the right track.

Name: Paul Elsworth
Age in 1870: 25
Birth Year: abt 1845
Birthplace: New York
Home in 1870: Lansing Ward 4, Ingham, Michigan
Post Office: Lansing
Occupation: Brick & Stone Mason
Household Members:
Paul Elsworth 25
Jane Elsworth 25
Elfretta Elsworth 2
William F Jones 10