I'm not sure if the "(Borden)" was intended to be Liddie's maiden name or another possibility if not BORDERS. Since you found the BORDERS in the 1900 census, we may have to check marriage records to see if Joel BORDERS married a Liddie BORDEN if it does appear to be a maiden name. Do you still have the census information for Liddie? Age birthplace, parents born where? If we are looking for any BORDEN ties, that informaion would be useful in narrowing the search.