I am also trying to find information about Mordecai Hotalen. I am a descendent through his daughter Rachel. Rachel married Robert Emmett McCarthy. Their daughter, Margaret Jane, married Leland Nelson Burke. They had a son, Leland Nelson Burke, Jr. and he was my father.
Could you please tell me more about the Minisink Valley Church? Could you also provide me with the database that tracks more historical ancestors of Mordecai?
Any information would be appreciated.