I really don't know anything about Indian descent and don't have a clue what happened to the 6-year old Sarah Gallop that was found in the 1860 census. I do know that Penelope Baum was 1st married to Mathias Toler (his will probated Aug. 1842) and they had a son (among other children) named James Hall Toler so the Hall name may have some significance here. In what county did James A. Hall, Jr. marry Sarah? I didn't find a marriage for them in Currituck or Dare Co.