I am searching ancestors of my 3g grandfather James Nunnaley who was born about 1810 - I wonder if there is any chance he is the son of Elisha Nunnally listed in your old bible.
My James Nunnaley may have the middle name Aaron. He married Katherine Flinn in Edgar, IL in 1833. I believe my James was from North Carolina or Virginia originally. Katherine's father Jacob B. Flinn was born in Surry Co., NC.