Sorry I haven't checked this in a a while! I do believe our Lovett and Benjamin are related. Not ony do we have a Lovett in our family we also have a Walter R.
I found a Walter Raleigh Moore who is about the same age as your Lovett and my Benjamin and I've wondered if they are all brothers. I also found an Etheldred who is about their same age and we have a few Eldridge's in our line - maybe a spin off of Etheldred. When you look at all of their families, they all seem to have many of the same names: Walter's, William's, Julia's and Lovett's.
We know from Y-DNA testing that we match almost perfectly with Moore's in Texas. This makes sense if Lovett is a brother of Benjamin because Arkansas borders Texas. Do you know of any of Lovett's family in Texas??