Thanks so much for the info! I saw Redding living with Jacob and Rebecca in 1860 and suspected he might be a brother. I can't find much on Jesse Hutchins. Do you think he might be the builder of the home?
I've seen references to a William Hutchins in the area but not sure if he's connected with the property.
I'm trying to determine if the property that the house is on was part of a larger 18th century grant.