I realize your post is old, but here is information I have:
Epenetus Everett Sr. was born in 1777, place unknown and died in 1838 in Kingswood, Hunterdon, NJ. Parents were Ezekiel and Mary Everett. I have 3 wives for him Mary Young, Elizabeth Wismer, and Abigail Vannoy.
I believe someof the information on dates are wrong, but here is what I have on Jr: Epenetus Jr. born Dec 1800 in Kingwood, Hunterdon, NJ (Mother was (Mary Young). He married Anna (Nancy) Rittenhouse in 1828 in Hunterdon. They had children Joseph, Epenetus III, Elizabeth, Ezekiel, Josiah, William, Zenas, Redden, and Mahlon. Mahlon was the last born in 1842 and his mother died in 1848. Epenetus then married Susannah Jane Pickering in 1851. I don't have any children listed for them. Epenetus died in 1885.
I have children listed under Epenetus, Sr. and Elizabeth Wismer: Josiah, Levi, Elizabeth,Zenus, and Epenetus N. I have no sourse for this information other than the internet, so consider it suspect.
Epenetus moved to Ohio between 1826 and 1830, as per letter from nephew Cornelius Quick (sister Mary's son) to Zenas Everitt dated 1867. Cornelius lists Epenetus's children as Ezekiel, twins Epenetus and Zenas, William, Joshiah the oldest, 3 daughters-one of whom married George Flowers.
In a census list, his name is written as "Neitis".
So, let me know how this fits with your information.