FINAL DAWES ROLL
Chickasaw Coyle Albert Pike 10 M 3/8 554 1653

Michelle,
You will need to do enough additional research to more specifically ID the particular person you are looking for.
In these Federal censuses, 42 adult Albert Coyles were enumerated: 1790, 1800, 1810, 1820, 1860, 1870,
1890, 1900,1910, 1920, 1930 (partial). The only Albert Pike Cole on the Chickasaw Dawes Roll is:
Chickasaw - Coyle, Albert Pike, b. c1890, DIB = 3/8, Family Card #554, Dawes enrollment #1653.

His father was Pike Coyle. If Albert was orphaned. it was after 1899 as his father continued to have children as late as that year who were also enrolled Chickasaws. (also, vd Clara Coyle, below).

In what state was the "Gainesville" where your Gaines family located? I could not locate "Gainesville" in Oklahoma.

In 1900, in the Chickasaw Nation, Indian Terr, there were 3 Coyle families:
John Coyle, his wife & Children, all white;
and,
Page 284B & 285A:
Clara Coyle, white, b. Nov 1866, TX/MO/MO, a widow, and her children:
Jim, b. Nov 1885, Ind Terr, father b. Ind Terr, mother b. TX
Albert, b. Feb 1888, I.T./I.T./TX === this appears to be the enrolled Albert Coyle.
Benjamin, b. Feb 1890, I.T./I.T./TX
Ernest, b. 1892, I.T./I.T./TX
Mabel, b. July 1890, I.T./I.T./TX
Audry, 1898, I.T./I.T./TX
Teresa, b. 1899, I.T./I.T./TX

and Thomas W. Coyle, white, 32, b. SC

In addition,
There are 12 Albert Coyles enumerated as heads of households in the 1900 Fed census, of those
this is the only one b. in 1859:

1900 - IOWA - DUBUQUE cnty, 5-WD DUBUQUE, Page: 183A
Albert Coyle, white, Nov 1859, 40, IL/NY/WI
Margaret, white, illeg 1863, married 18 yrs, IA/ME/Scotland
James, white, Dec 1882, IA/IL/IA
Agnes, white, 1888, IA/IL/IA
Albert, July 1892, IA/IL/IA
There are others born in 1858, 1857, 1856

Then there are these other Albert P. &/or Albert Pike Coyles on the census:
1910 - WASHINGTON - BENTON cnty, PROSSER PCT, Page: 247B
Albert P. Coyle, white, 67, OH/PA/Ireland
Margaret E., white, 64, PA/PA/PA

1920 - INDIANA - CLARK cnty, SILVER CRK TWP, Page: 231B
Albert P. Coyle, white, 29, IN/IN/IN
Mabel, white, 29, IN/IN/IN
Lewis H., white, 3, IN/IN/IN
Elizabeth, white, 3/12, IN/IN/IN

1920 - OKLAHOMA - LOVE cnty, BURNEY, Page: 175B
Albert Pike Coyle,mulatto*, 31,OK/OK/OK
Ida L., white, 30, OK/MO/TN
* indexed at Heritage Quest as mulatto - image appears to say white.

good luck.