Thanks so much ! Yes, I know this is also a Shamokin Twp., as I lived there for 25 years ! Right smack between Sunbury & Shamokin. I believe my problem is that the city directories were for BOTH the cities of Sunbury & Shamokin, and so it lists people living in Shamokin, when they were living in the city of Sunbury. This I do know as FACT...they were my grandparents, ans they never lived in the city of Shamokin. But Boyds city directories have both cities listed and on Ancestry.com, it says Shamokin. It makes things very confusing ! Again, my thanks !