Here's a possibility. Do you have any additional info on your Samuel?

Series: M653 Roll: 1052 Page: 83
1860 - Center Twp., Williams Co., OH - 7/26/1860
Coltender, Saml. - 32 - farmer - $2,000/400 - NY
-- Mary - 26 - OH
-- Susan F. - 7 mos. - OH

Series: M593 Roll: 393 Page: 242
1870 - Thompson - Guthrie Co., IA - 8/23/1870
Coltrider, Saml. - 42 - farmer - $..00/800 - NY
-- Mary - 34 - OH
-- Laura - 10 - OH
-- Warren - 6 - OH
-- Flora - 2 - OH
He.., Taylor - 21 - labr. - OH

Series: T9 Roll: 342 Page: 38
1880 - Thompson, Guthrie Co., IA - 6/21-22/1880
Coltrider, S. - 52 - head - farmer - NY/PA/MD
-- Sarah - 31 - wife - housekeeping - PA/PA/PA
-- Laura - 19 - dau. - OH/NY/PA
-- Warren - 15 - son - OH/NY/PA
-- Flora - 11 - dau. - OH/NY/PA
-- A..is - 7 - son - IA/NY/PA

Series: T623 Roll: 434 Page: 73
1900 - Grant Twp., Guthrie Co., IA - 6/7/1900
Coltrider, Samuel - head - 12/1825 - 74 - married 27 yrs. - NY/MD/PA - farmer - own/free/farm
-- Sarah - wife - 7/1848 - 51 - married 27 yrs. - 3 children/3 living - OH/unknown/PA
-- Sumner - son - 3/1883 - 17 - single - IA/NY/OH - farm laborer
-- Nellie - dau. - 5/1885 - 5 - single - IA/NY/OH