Here are some things to consider.
Hovis is Horace. He died in 24 Nov 1950.
When Horace was baptised as an adult in 1950 at ST JOSEPH'S CATHOLIC CHURCH in York. It is recorded that his father was Horace which I don't believe, and his mother was Anna Laird. There is some confusion about Laird but the first 2 lettes are definitly L and A. In 1918 when Horace married Mary Peddicord he says his father is George and his mother is Annie Laird. In 1900 Annie says she was born Mar 1836. In 1898 Harry and Horace are living in Slab, a small hamlet in Lower Chanceford Twp.. The 1880 census has Harry and Hovis with Nancy Dawson in the home of Edmon Roades. Later he is Edward E and she is Leah Jane. She died 1896 and he died 4 Dec 1904.
On Harry's marriage licence he says his mother is Anna Dawson and no father is listed. He married Flora 16 Dec 1890 in Sunnyburn, a small town in Lower Chanceford Twp.
In 1860 Samuel Rhode of Paradise is Samuel Roth/Rath of Jackson Twp and Nancy is 19.
In Anna Dawson's obit in 1919 she is the wife of George and list children Harry, Horace and Catherine.