I have a record (from Find-a-Grave in Sidener Cemetery in LaGrange Co IN) that states:
"Born in Codorus, York, Pennsylvania (6 May 1794) Justina Catherina was the daughter of Zacharias and Catherine Neidig Shue. On June 16, 1816 in York, Pennsylvania, she married Andrew Hinkle at the First Trinity Reformed Lutheran Church. She and Andrew became the parents of John, William, Amos, Catherine (Snyder), Elizabeth (Snyder), the twins; Aquila and Priscilla and Jacob G. Hinkle."
That would make her grandparents Zacharias Shue and Anna Maria Klein. I have been trying to track down his ancestry with no luck. I did find out that he had a Dutch Bible in his possession.
Eric von Dorster, son of Nellie Virginia Shue