We are from the same Rutherford family
Abraham H. Rutherford was my 4th great grandfather, his siblings Sarah A. Dodd Harris, James M. Rutherford (1822 – 1889), William P. (1826 – 1889), Charles Henry (1828 – 1900), Robert A. (1830 – 1901), Elizabeth (1832 – bef 1889), Larkin B. (1836 – 1928) & Rachel Adaline Moss (1842-1918), all children of Larkin Rutherford & Frances Hester.
James M. Rutherford & Nancy Cantrell married in McMinn County, Tennessee on July 13, 1843 and their children James Larkin, Jacob H., Thomas M., William, Nancy Elizabeth Jane *, Mary Clarinda, David Cantrell, Margaret and John M.. My line of Rutherford's also settled in Comanche County, Texas. ;)
I have your ancestor in my records as Nancy Elizabeth Jane Rutherford