We would love to see a picture of Charles. As you probably surmised from my original post, my husband is related to your Charles through Charles Pinkney Welch and Mary B. Shropshire and also related to Sulie through Seaborn Jefferson Thornton and Mary Elizabeth Wicker. I would really like to share any information and pictures I have that you may not have. Do you have a tree on Ancestry? or elsewhere online? Anxiously awaiting your answer. We also live in California.