I see you have done a lot of work. But the Patrick I am looking for had four sons from Katie Mack and would have been quiet young at the time he married Ann Murphy and they are not mention anywhere. All of the boys moved here to Worcester Frank marrying Elizabeth Kerwin and when she passed married and moved to Milford, MA. Leaving one son in the care of his sister-in-law. Frederick went into the service and I have lost track of him. Thomas Daniel (Thomas H) married moved to Boston then moved to Penn and had two children and I believed died there. So unless they had a son together and names him Thomas (which would be odd since he all ready had a son Thomas in 1881 with katie)So with that said this family may not be mine. It fits till that point. I can not find Patrick and Kaite in any census or Directories. I have the boys birth certificatesall born in Putney. But I will keep looking on that site to see what I can find. Thank ou for your hard work. If you come up with anything else please let me know.