Thanks. I assume that the mariage to Jesse Massie should show Caroline E. Davidson versus Caroline S. Davidson. The lineage of Caroline E. Davidson appears to have been:
1 David Davidson (born in Holland; died about 1687 in James City Co., VA) + Sarah Unknown
Part of DNA "Family 10" at www.davidsongenes.org
2 David Davidson, Junior (died about 1756 in Charles City CO., VA) + Unknown wife
3) David Davidson (born about 1715 in James Vity Co., VA; died about 1798 in Buckingham Co., VA) + Mary Giles
4) Giles Davidson (born about 1762 in Buckingham Co., VA; he was present at the surender of Corwallis in Yorktown, VA; he moved to Amherst Co., VA) + Gimina/Jermina Pendleton.
5) Caroline E. Davidson