It does seem to be a conundrum doesn't it? I do have references to dates of birth, death (on Susannah #2) and marriage dates but some insist that they are one and the same person. I've seen references to Susannah #2 parents but not Susannah #1 along with no dod for #1. I wonder how they are related?
The records on Ancestry.com confuse the two and only seem to reference Susannah #2 with both marriage dates ect.
I appreciate all the response and help that people are offering. Thank you!