According to a list of Toler marriages compiled by Anita Toler Baudean in 1990, Elizabeth Toler dau/Joseph & Frances Dixon Toler m. John Shockley on 8/4/1807, in Pittsylvania Co. VA. Then later it says: Elizabeth Toler dau/ Elijah & Polly Rorher Toler m. Shadrack Shockley son/John & Elizabeth Toler Shockley on 12/17/1828 in Pittsylvania Co. VA. The Elijah Toler mentioned here is also the son of Joseph & Frances Dixon Toler. Elijah Toler m. Polly Rorher on 10/13/1807 in Pittsylvania Co. VA. Joseph Toler m. Frances Dixon ca. 1770 in Pittsylvania Co. VA. The list also says that Joseph Toler is the son of William Toler of Hartford Co. VA.