I also have Payns that settled in LaPorte Co., IN before moving onto Berlin, Green Lakes Co., Wisconsin.
Eratus H. (b. in Conn.) and Jerusha (born in Conn in 1793 & d. 1863) Payn: They had two children that I know about:
1. ANSEL F. PAYN who m. Julia Palmer on Apr. 1, 1846 in LaPorte Co., IN. (They had a son Frances who was born in Berlin and married Julia Brewer)
2. ALONZO D. PAYN who was born in NY & died in Berlin on Aug. 25, 1895. He married Mary Jane McClintock Sept. 24, 1839 in LaPorte Co.