The mystery is partially solved. Hattie Maria Caldwell (1839-1919) is from a Wayne County, NY family. Married Unknown Wade. She was the daughter of Elsemina and Isaac Caldwell. Her siblings include Isaac, John, Thomas, Louisa, Mary, Margaret, Chloana and perhaps Hannah. She is buried in Lot 40 of the Walworth Village Cemetery (Wayne County), NY. It turns out that Lucy Ann (Turner) Tuttle (1836-1924) is her cousin, not her daughter as originally thought. Lucy Ann Turner was the daughter of Mary Caldwell (listed above) and Silas Turner. She married William Wallace Tuttle in 1856 in Walworth, NY. Their fourth child, Harriet (Tuttle) Tinklepaugh (1875-1963), was named for Hattie Maria (Caldwell) Wade and was also called Hattie. Photograph of Hattie Maria (Caldwell) Wade recently found and identified. Scan available. Old photo is from a Ettrick, Wisconsin studio. Not sure of the connection to Wisconsin, perhaps fleeting. Everybody else seems to be back in NY except for a portion of the Tuttles who seem to have resided there briefly in the 1860's. Perhaps she had her picture made there while on a visit to that branch of the family. Not my lines, so I don't have additional information on any of these families; glad to point you to the descendants who helped me id the photograph if you are connected.