I suspected Scenty might be Cynthia Nicholson. She died very young, especially compared to some of the others.
David Hollenback must have loved Australia to stay behind when his father and brother left. Until I saw the passenger list with "D Hollenback 60", I didn't know his father came too. When I could find no records for him in Indiana after 1850, I thought he died. Now I'm going to have to see if he made it to Liverpool, England then back to the USA.
With the help of all of you I'm beginning to unravel the mess I had with this family.
Is there a chance a marriage record for David & Katherine Carey/Carney might be available, or Katherine's death record. I picked up her name from the death records of her 3 oldest children the one year I paid for Ancestry's World subscription.
Again, thank you all for helping me!!!
P.S. If there's a living descendant of either Cynthia Violet or Carol Lavina Nicholson, I'd sure like to hear from them.