His last wife was Ann Robinson Kruck born in Minnesota in 1870. She was a widow with 2 children when she married Philip Roder in 1891. According to the censuses her father was Scottish and her mother German. Philip was from Belgium. I've been doing research for a descendant from her daughter, Flora Kruck. His first wife was Palien also from Belgium according to the census. I did not research Palien further because this branch is not a direct line.