I'm certain of the identity of my Great Great Grandfather, Frederick Phelps. However, I am at a dead end with the Phelps here. Frederick was born about 1825. Birthplace is given as New York. His wife was Caroline Amelia Eames, born in Vermont. After Frederick died in 1876, Caroline remarried--David Farnum. My Great Grandfather, Louis/Lewis Phelps is listed on the 1880 census as a stepson of the head of household and husband to Caroline--David Farnum. Louis had six or seven siblings; one of whom, Walter Elmer, had ten children. There is a lot of info from them. However, nothing beyond Frederick in the Phelps line. There might be a connection to Belinda Sunderlin, b. 1799, who married a Phelps--possibly named Almeron Phelps?