Hi Jennifer,
I was just looking for information on my Cotter family and noticed your Smith/Stillwell/Atwater information. Since I have both Stillwell and Atwater in my family, I thought I'd write. I also descend from Caleb Atwater. I was born in Ithaca, Tompkins County but have lived in Rochester, NY for many years. Please email me at Rici@rochester.rr.com and we can "talk."

Patricia Stillwell Mims