Samuel and Elizabeth Graybeal were my great great grandparents. Samuel II was my great grandfather. I did not know about the 2nd wife. My dates for Samuel II B 1847 and Jacob B 1848 must be in error.I have Elizabeth's death 1857. Have not been able to find Samuel I in 1850 census. Marriage date for Sam and Mary 1859. Does your information match this?
There are so many Bachtels in the area hard to find the connection our Sam indicates Baden Germany as birth place. Most of the others have Maryland or Penna. Family stories have him coming to Ohio with three brothers but I have never been able to confirm this.
Love to share informton with you. Contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org