Shelly, I descend from Nancy Agnes Binnegar. I have had John Binnegar listed as her father for some time (but no firm documentation). I just recently was notified via e-mail that her mother was Ann Marl. I have asked for the source of this information, but as yet have not had any response. Nancy Agnes married John Franklin Harris Sr. in 1801 and they had 11 children. I have info on them if you are interested. Do you have any source tying Nancy Agnes and her siblings to John Binnegar? You can contact me directly at wchad@aol.com. I look forward to hearing from you. Bill