My grandmother was Phoebe Ella Bywater, born 1880 in Wolverhampton, the daughter of William Gaunt Bywater and Mary Ann Benton. The Bywater side of my family presents no problems but Phoebe's husband, Edward Murray is a different thing. I have been unable to find any info on him except in 1891 when he was living with his relations(nephew)John and Mary Ann Lawton in Wolverhampton. Anyone out there who has any info on Edward?