I wonder how my Caddys are connected with yours as they are all from the same Area of Cornwall. I have gone back to 1792 when Joseph Caddy was born he would be my GGGG Grandfather. I wonder if your John was a Brother of his? I will try and do a bit more digging as it would be nice to add a bit more to the tree. The Cady name has now died out on my side of the family unfortunately my Mum and her sisters being the last. Notice the spelling changed to Cady not sure why it seems to be form my GG Father. He was a Colour Sargent in the Royal Marines and I have a wonderful diary that he kept form 1906 - 1908. Have you seen the post from Beachnana on the forum under my Cady search? She is looking for your Caddys. Think she was called Beachnana.