The origin of info is cited as a book; however, what were the sources cited in the book? Seems odd: David Robert Caldwell b. 1759, d. 1855 but possibly served in Confederatcy(sic)5-6 yrs after he died? Rebecca Park Caldwell's descendents appear to be varied and legion on the internet--reputable source(s)for which are never cited. Given the number of Caldwells extant in up country South Carolina in the 18th century I fear that many Caldwell lines have been conflated and attached to Rebecca!