My husband's grandfather was Andrew Jackson Carroll, or Carrell. The family spells it differently even brothers. But Andrew J. father was Simon from Penn. and ancesters came from Ireland. Simon is as far as we get, can't seen to find his father. Andrew was born in 1844 or 1845, Supposedly fought in the Civil War. We think he took someone else's place. Was not registered.
I don't think this is the Andrew you are looking for, but their may be a connection somewhere.