I think there must be some connection as the names seem very familiar.

My Thomas GAUNT had daughters Sarah, Selina, Judith, Lucy and son Arthur. Selina went on to have Annie who married and became a WEBSTER and Amy (b. 1910) who married and became RIMMER. Judith m. MANLEY. Lucy m. ROBERTS. Arthur m. Gleason.Sarah m. first ROBINSON and then HORNE.

Since they often named children after people in their family the link between Selina, Anne and Amy seems quite a strong possibility for a link to me. Also we know that there was an Elizabeth, a Catherine and a Kitty (possibly the same Catherine's pet name) but we don't know the relationship or where they came in the family, these are just family names my relative remembered being mentioned. Maybe Thomas was James's brother? I will call again on my relative (daughter of Sarah ) to see if she remembers any married names or middle names etc.

Thanks for such a quick reply.
Regards Lynette