My Joel CHUBB, b. 1 August 1808 in NY; d. abt 1860 in Rockford, Winnebago, IL (can't find a death record or gravestone) m. Sarah (Sally) Ann DYER 18 Nov. 1821 in Geouga, Ohio (she was b. 25 Nov 1808 in NY and d. 30 June 1893 in Baxter Springs, Cherokee, KS)

I am looking for the parents of Joel CHUBB. I believe his grandparents were Alexander CHUBB of Pittsford, Ontario,NY and his wife Mindwell WHEELER. His parents may have been Alexander's son, Harvey and his wife Caroline. The only other Chubb in the 1810 census with a male under age 10, was Gideon CHUBB of Columbia Co. His family doesn't fit as well as Alexander's. (Joel had a son named James Harvey; Sally or Sarah DYER's father was James. Also Alexander had a daugher named Claret and so did Joel. There was also a son named Horace Wheeler (for Mindwell Wheeler?).