Actually, I have three "Mary Cole" ancestors. Two are descended from John Cole and the other is not, as far as I know.
That Mary Cole was born 1758 and died 1838 in NY. She married Henry Kline (Cline.)
The other Marys, down from John were:
Mary b. 1688 in Stonington, CT.
Mary b 1763 and married Benjamin Gallup.