Don't have a Rachel Cole that I know of. I do have another Cole line thru NY/PA that I have never found anything on yet. My g-g-grandmother, Harriet Ellen Cole b. 11 Oct 1835 (Dunkirk, Chautauqua, NY?) (census says PA) who married David Elisha Dodge b. 1831 to parents David E. and Maria (Cole) Dodge. If I find any links between your Rachel and my Harriet Ellen, I'll contact you asap.