More evidence indicating James Sr. having the following children as indicated by the 1830 census in Independence, Allegany, NY-listed as "Jas Cstly":

1 male 5-10:could be Cleveland M.(8yrs)

3 males 10-15:could be Lewis B. (10yrs), Eldad M. (12yrs), William A. (14yrs)

2 males 15-20:could be Philander (16yrs), Philo C. (18yrs)

1 males 50-60:could be James, Sr. (would be abt 59yrs)

1 female 40-50:could be Margaret (would be abt 47yrs) also possible to be Silvia if she returned

Note: This seems to back up the 1820 census of James SR with these children, along with the addition of my gg grandfather Cleveland b. 1822. It appears the three girls in earlier census data (the 2 older girls are missing from the 1820 census as well) have either married or passed away. James JR and Charles are living near one another in Tioga, PA.

Anyone have sources indicating a Charles Costlee and Jane Campbell are James SR's parents? I can only find their marriage record online, and a user submitted tree with no sources sited.

Penny