Can't help you much, but they may be related to my ancestors. Chas Cutler (b 1824) came to WI from VT. His son Chas. E Cutler (b. 1847) and Chas E's son, Bert S. Cutler,(b. 1882), lived in Dodge County, WI. Can't imagine there would be too many unrelated Cutlers in Dodge County at that time.
Bert was my gr. grandfather. Chas E. and his wife Lizzie, did have a son named George, who was born ~1878. He was 2 at the time of the 1880 census.