I'm also descended from James Cutler who arrived in the colonies in 1634. My line follows yours down thru Lt. Thomas, Thomas, Abner and Joel. My Gr-gr-gr-gr Grandpa was Joel's son and Asa's brother, Thaddeus. Then to Charles, Charles E., Bert, and my Grandmother Laura M. Cutler. Charles moved to WI, where my family resides.
Any info you could tell me about the early Cutlers would be appreciated, Cousin. :D