Danny, I don't think that we are related, at least since the Cutlers arrived in the United States.
Back in England, maybe. I need more information. Can you give me information on Sam Cutler from Staffordshire, where born, marriage, children and when he came to the U.S. and as much detail as you have in the states. I work in the Family History Center here and could look in more detail there. If you could give me your email address, I could reply directly to you.
My earlist ancester is Humphry (Humpfride on the church records) 1698, Chesterfield, Derbyshire. Let me know.